Chalk one up for the good guys… Today a U.S. district judge ruled against (more like annihilated) the Dover, Pennsylvania school board who tried to force “intelligent design” into their Grade 9 biology classes.
The judge’s 139-page decision is here, and if it’s not quite of the sheer literary quality of the City of Toronto’s Bellamy report, it’s a remarkably straightforward (not too much legalese) and lucid retelling of facts: starting with a backgrounder featuring the history of creationism vs. evolution in the US courts; all the way through the machinations and outright lying of the born-again board members to push their agenda through. I was just shaking my head at details such as:
…there arose the astonishing story of an evolution mural that was taken from a classroom and destroyed in 2002 by Larry Reeser, the head of buildings and grounds for the [board]. At the June 2004 meeting, [teacher] Spahr asked [board member and creationist] Buckingham where he had received a picture of the evolution mural that had been torn down and incinerated…. Buckingham responded: “I gleefully watched it burn.” Buckingham disliked the mural because he thought it advocated the theory of evolution, particularly common ancestry. Burning the evolutionary mural apparently was insufficient for Buckingham, however. Instead, he demanded that the teachers agree that there would never again be a mural depicting evolution in any of the classrooms and in exchange, Buckingham would agree to support the purchase of the biology textbook in need by the students.
But we probably shouldn’t get too cocky about winning this one; in the judge’s conclusion:
…this case came to us as the result of the activism of an ill-informed faction on a school board…to adopt an imprudent and ultimately unconstitutional policy. The breathtaking inanity of the Board’s decision is evident when considered against the factual backdrop which has now been fully revealed through this trial.
That is, these people were stupid. This won’t always be the case (though one hopes it will be).
